| Islip | Comsewogue | |
|---|---|---|
| vs East Islip | W 13-9 | W 9-6 |
| vs Eastport-South Manor | L 4-10 | L 7-17 |
| vs Harborfields | W 7-6 | L 12-13 |
| vs Miller Place | L 3-5 | W 8-6 |
| vs Rocky Point | L 6-7 | W 14-4 |
| vs Sayville | L 7-13 | L 5-17 |
| vs Smithtown East | W 17-6 | W 12-4 |
| vs Smithtown West | L 8-9 | L 10-12 |
| vs West Babylon | W 14-5 | W 16-4 |
| vs West Islip | L 7-13 | L 7-12 |
