| St Peters Staten Island | St Joseph By-The-Sea | |
|---|---|---|
| vs Archbishop Molloy | L 2-5 | W 12-6 |
| vs Bishop Loughlin | W 6-4 | W 12-7 |
| vs Cardinal Spellman | W 12-1 | W 12-3 |
| vs Curtis | L 4-11 | L 5-10 |
| vs Kennedy Catholic | L 1-10 | L 5-8 |
| vs Monsignor Farrell | L 2-11 | L 6-10 |
| vs Moore Catholic | W 7-6 | W 13-3 |
| vs Mount St Michael | W 6-0 | W 15-2 |
| vs New Dorp | W 8-3 | W 16-4 |
| vs St John Baptist | L 5-7 | W 11-6 |
| vs Xaverian | L 3-7 | W 8-6 |
| vs Xavier | L 1-11 | W 11-4 |
