| Watkins Glen/Notre Dame | Owego Apalachin | |
|---|---|---|
| vs Chenango Forks | L 11-21 | L 11-20 |
| vs Chenango Valley | L 6-19 | L 9-21 |
| vs Dryden | W 19-4 | W 12-5 |
| vs Johnson City | L 7-8 | L 9-12 |
| vs Maine-Endwell | L 9-18 | L 7-20 |
| vs Seton Catholic Central | L 7-15 | W 14-10 |
| vs Whitney Point | L 7-20 | L 8-16 |
| vs Windsor Central | W 15-10 | W 15-1 |
